Counselling versus Clinical Psychology

03/11/2024

The distinction between counselling/psychotherapy and clinical psychology services lies primarily in training, scope of practice, theoretical orientation, and clinical governance. While all can offer valuable mental health support, they differ significantly in depth of clinical expertise, diagnostic authority, and intervention approaches, particularly for complex, neurodivergent or high-risk presentations.

Key Differences Between Counselling/Psychotherapy and Clinical Psychology

When Is Clinical Psychology More Appropriate?

Clinical psychology services are generally more appropriate when:

  • There is complexity, co-occurring conditions and concerns, or diagnostic uncertainty
  • Standardised assessment or diagnostic clarification is needed
  • The child or adult requires a neuroaffirmative formulation integrating cognitive, developmental, emotional, and systemic factors. Where there are complexities treatment should understand the individual client from a whole-brain and Bio-Psycho-Social perscpective
  • The case involves risk, trauma, self-harm, suicidality, or safeguarding concerns
  • Parents, schools, or other professionals need formal recommendations, psychological reports, or accommodations planning
  • A whole-systems, multidisciplinary perspective is required (e.g., education plans, disability supports, clinical referrals)

When Is Counselling/Psychotherapy More Appropriate?

Talk-based counselling or psychotherapy may be ideal for:

  • Situational stress, typical life transitions, uncomplicated grief, or relational difficulties (where autism traits/characteristics are well understood and supported neuroaffirmatively)
  • Supporting mental wellbeing in a non-directive or exploratory way
  • Clients who prefer longer-term, talking-based support that is not diagnosis-focused or goal-oriented
  • Autistic or neurodivergent clients seeking identity-affirming, low-demand, reflective therapeutic relationships (if the therapist is suitably informed and experienced and alternative means of developing and maintaining social connectedness with other autistics is also supported and not more appropriate for the client's wellbeing). For example, due consideration has been given to the appropriateness of developing a temporary supportive relationship with an adult therapist (neuro-typical versus neuro-divergent) over developing meaningful and lasting connectedness with peers in the community via supportive groups and special interest activities/events.


A Neuroaffirmative Caveat

  • Many neurodivergent individuals benefit from identity-affirming psychotherapy, but misalignment of training, use of pathologizing language, or lack of neurodevelopmental understanding can lead to ineffective or negative outcomes.
  • Clinical psychologists are generally trained to adapt therapy for executive functioning challenges, sensory differences, alexithymia, monotropism, or social fatigue — though not all do so in a neuroaffirmative way, specialist training and experience is required.
  • Families should seek professionals with specialist knowledge and evidence-based practices, particularly for autistic, ADHD, PDA, dyslexic, or twice-exceptional (2e) children.

Further knowledge on best practice for neurodivergent children and adults can be found on the following websites:

🌍 International Guidelines & Clinical Practice Frameworks

  1. NICE Guidelines – Autism (UK)
    Comprehensive guidance on assessment, support, and interventions for autistic children and adults.
    🔗 https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg170
    🔗 https://www.nice.org.uk/guidance/cg142 (Adults)

  2. National Autism Implementation Team (Scotland)
    Leading model in neuroaffirmative clinical practice in public services.
    🔗 https://www.sdwellbeing.scot/nait

  3. WHO – Mental Health Gap Action Programme (mhGAP)
    Frameworks for adapting psychological care in developmental disorders globally.
    🔗 https://www.who.int/teams/mental-health-and-substance-use/treatment-care/mental-health-gap-action-programme

🇮🇪 Irish-Specific Best Practice Resources

  1. Psychological Society of Ireland (PSI)
    Check position papers, CPD events, and divisional guidance (especially Clinical and Educational Psychology divisions).
    🔗 https://www.psychologicalsociety.ie

  2. AsIAm – Ireland's Autism Charity
    Advocacy-driven, offers neurodiversity-affirming educational content and supports.
    🔗 https://www.asiam.ie

  3. National Council for Special Education (NCSE)
    Resources for psychologists and educators on supporting autistic students in Irish schools.
    🔗 https://ncse.ie

Neuroaffirmative Practice

Use image sections to split the content visually

Besides the headings, the image sections do a great job in splitting the content in the right places. Main sections of your blog post can be separated by the images, corresponding with the topic you cover.

You can also use blockquote formatting to emphasize the cited sources.

This is where your text starts. You can click here and start typing. Sed ut perspiciatis unde omnis iste natus error sit voluptatem accusantium doloremque laudantium totam rem aperiam eaque ipsa quae ab illo inventore veritatis et.